From School Pushouts to Graduating College: A Counter-narrative of Highly Educated Black Males

Show simple item record

dc.contributor.author Cabbell, Mustapha A.
dc.coverage.spatial United States en_US
dc.coverage.temporal 2020-2021 en_US
dc.date.accessioned 2021-08-23T20:10:12Z
dc.date.available 2021-08-23T20:10:12Z
dc.date.issued 2021-07
dc.identifier.other D3704231-8A26-39B3-41E0-D864F7EE9B74 en_US
dc.identifier.uri https://hdl.handle.net/10428/4987
dc.description.abstract To provide stories of how successful Black males made meaning of their educational experiences and offer current students motivation for focusing on their education, I conducted a qualitative study of four successful Black males from an urban area bordering a large southern city. Successful meant earning a college degree. Data collected through using Seidman’s three-phase interview process was transcribed and then analyzed in MAXQDA software using in vivo, emotion, axial, and pattern coding. Sports, relationships, and goal setting were found to be the main reasons for academic success. However, seven themes were constructed from the data and presented as a counter-narrative: succeeding through sports, building relationships with school personnel, setting goals and positive attitudes for success, influencing others to succeed, learning from mistakes, choosing good people, and succeeding through friendships. A discussion of each theme synthesized participants’ experiences to provide ways these Black males perceived their success, to inform educators of beneficial experiences, and to encourage young Black men to finish their education. Institutional racism was experienced and exposed in the counter-narrative. Keywords: Black males, deficit thinking, counter-narrative, in vivo coding, axial coding, pattern coding, institutional racism en_US
dc.description.tableofcontents CHAPTER I: INTRODUCTION 1 -- Background of Study 1 -- Statement of Problem 8 -- Significance of this Study 10 -- Research Goals and Questions 12 -- Conclusion 13 -- CHAPTER II: CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK 15 -- Personal Experiences 16 -- Identity and Positionality 22 -- Theoretical Framework 24 -- Cultural Deficit Theory 25 -- Critical Race Theory 26 -- Permanence of racism 27 -- Colorblindness 28 -- Whiteness as property. 29 -- Counter-narrative 29 -- Interest convergence 31 -- Social justice 31 -- African American Male Theory 32 -- Literature Review 34 -- Black Leaders for Equity 35 -- W. E. B. Du Bois 36 -- Derrick Bell 37 -- Malcolm X 38 -- Patricia Hill Collins 39 -- Bell Hooks 39 -- Sandy Grande 41 -- Cornel West 41 -- Summary. 41 -- Current Reality 42 -- Dropout or Pushout 45 -- Whiteness and Permanence of Racism 48 -- Characteristics of Success and Culture 51 -- Experiences 54 -- Incorporating Culture 57 -- Eurocentric Worldview 59 -- Afrocentric Worldview as a Strategy 59 -- Conclusion 61 -- CHAPTER III: RESEARCH DESIGN 62 -- Research Questions 62 -- Research Methods 65 -- Research Design: Counter-narrative + Case Study 65 -- Setting and Participant Selection 68 -- Setting. 68 -- Participants 71 -- Research Relationships 75 -- Data Collection 76 -- Data Analysis 80 -- Data Presentation 91 -- Validity 95 -- Conclusion 99 -- CHAPTER IV: BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCHES OF CHARACTERS 101 -- Abjiel 101 -- Ant 109 -- Sting 115 -- Davis 119 -- Narrator 124 -- Conclusion 126 -- CHAPTER V: THE CREW: A COUNTER-NARRATIVE 127 -- Prologue 128 -- The Crew 128 -- Six Years Earlier 129 -- Abjiel’s Mistakes 130 -- Beginning of a Friendship 136 -- Middle School Sports 139 -- People Who Cared 141 -- High School Sports 144 -- Coaching Mentors 149 -- A Bad Experience from Which to Learn 155 -- A Brother’s Mistake 158 -- Plan for Success 164 -- The Crew Grows 167 -- Success is an Attitude 170 -- Friends Forever 172 -- Ten Years Later 173 -- Conclusion 173 -- CHAPTER VI: THEMES AND IMPLICATIONS FROM THE DATA 174 -- Succeeding through Sports 174 -- Building Relationships with School Personnel 178 -- Succeeding through Friendships 181 -- Learning from Mistakes or Difficulties 183 -- Setting Goals and Attitudes for Success 185 -- Choosing Good People 187 -- Influencing Others to Succeed 189 -- Conclusion 191 -- CHAPTER VII: INSTITUTIONAL RACISM EXPOSED 193 -- Systemic Racism 193 -- Microaggressions 196 -- Low Expectations 198 -- Inequalities 200 -- Conclusion 203 -- CHAPTER VIII: CONCLUSION 204 -- Research Questions Revisited 204 -- Further Study 206 -- Limitations 207 -- Final Thoughts 208 -- REFERENCES 210 -- Appendix A: IRB Approval 223 -- Appendix B: Participant Questionnaire 225 -- Appendix C: First Interview Topics 227 -- Appendix D: Second Interview Topics 229 -- Appendix E: Third Interview Topics 231 -- Appendix F: Research Journal 233 en_US
dc.format.extent 1 electronic document, 246 pages. 1951047 bytes. en_US
dc.format.mimetype application/pdf en_US
dc.language.iso en_US en_US
dc.rights This dissertation is protected by the Copyright Laws of the United States (Public Law 94-553, revised in 1976). Consistent with fair use as defined in the Copyright Laws, brief quotations from this material are allowed with proper acknowledgement. Use of the materials for financial gain with the author's expressed written permissions is not allowed. en_US
dc.subject Dissertations, Academic--United States en_US
dc.subject African American men en_US
dc.subject Racism en_US
dc.subject College graduates en_US
dc.title From School Pushouts to Graduating College: A Counter-narrative of Highly Educated Black Males en_US
dc.type Dissertation en_US
dc.contributor.department Department of Leadership, Technology, and Workforce Development of the James L. and Dorothy H. Dewar College of Education and Human Services en_US
dc.description.advisor Schmertzing, Richard W.
dc.description.committee Schmertzing, Lorraine
dc.description.committee Martinez, James
dc.description.degree Ed.D. en_US
dc.description.major Education in Curriculum and Instruction en_US


Files in this item

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record

Search Vtext


Advanced Search

Browse

My Account